July 14, 2020
Breaking News
Home » PRODUCTS » Mascara » Best Thickening Mascara Drugstore Vs Organic Bought Online?

Best Thickening Mascara Drugstore Vs Organic Bought Online?

When comparing mascaras designed to give you thicker lashes, likely the most important factor that you will consider is how well they work at adding length and fullness to your thin and lifeless lashes.  However, there are some other things you should think about when shopping or the best thickening mascara. After all, it’s being applied to your own natural lashes and so you should think about more than just how effective they are going to be at giving you the look of human hair eyelashes or silk eyelash extensions.

What about the ingredients?  Sure, you aren’t eating your mascara (we hope) but it’s no secret that some of the contents of even the best thickening mascara are less than safe.  And, while seeking out organic options used to be a painstaking and expensive task, times have changed as consumers have gotten more on board with non toxic makeup options and this has led to them becoming not only more readily available, but less expensive as well.


Popular products from the drugstore such as Covergirl Exact Eyelights Mascara score an ominous “8” with cosmetics database Skin Deep.  This is because the mascara ingredients contained in this popular product include elements like propylparaben, a preservative that is known not only to be a potential allergen, but also purported to disturb the endocrine system in humans.  And, while it’s claimed by many to be one of the best thickening mascara products on the market, you might be less than excited about picking up this undesirable compound containing mascara. Sorry, Covergirl!

10 Drugstore Mascaras to Avoid

Physician’s Formula Organic Wear is a product that will finally allow you to not only get yourself a product that is well reviewed to be one of the best thickening mascara products you can buy, it’s also all natural, organic and almost half of the ingredients contained inside are acquired from organic farming.  While its safety is given an impressive “1” for low risk by Skin Deep, and an  “8,” a high health safety rating from Good Guide, a consumer product safety resource, that’s not all there is to love about this elegantly packaged product.  Thicker and fuller lashes have been reported by satisfied users who hail it as the best thickening mascara for the money (around $16), and you can also benefit from the nourishing ingredients contained in this organic cosmetic as well such as leaf oil. This is Valeria’s (of Minki Lashes) go-to drugstore mascara for lower lashes when wearing luxurious real mink eyelashes by Minki Lashes!

View Minki Lashes Collection


Online you will find a much larger variety of cosmetics, and may be able to snag yourself up a bottle of smudge-proof Reviva Labs Mascara (Black Hypoallergenic; around $6 – buy at www.vitacost.com or www.iherb.com). The humectant and solvent PEG-20 is its most sinister component (rated “3” for medium risk by Skin Deep for non-reproductive organ system toxicity) but most remaining ingredients are not risky.

Honeybee Gardens Truly Natural Mascara is an even safer (yet not waterproof) organic option that bears an impressive ingredient safety rating of “1” for low-risk by Skin Deep. This product doesn’t contain ingredients from the paraben family and is considered a pretty safe choice for use around your sensitive and important eyes.  It is free of harsh chemicals and is an all natural formula.

10 Best Organic Mascaras
Valeria’s Best Smudge-Proof Thickening Mascara Tip: Apply 1-2 coats of Honeybee Gardens or Physician’s Formula mascara on your eyelashes and add an extra coat of paraben-free Reviva Labs for a smudge-proof day long wear.

Reminder: If you wear real mink eyelashes by Minki Lashes, avoid applying mascara to the false lashes. Use the suggested mascara options above on your bottom eyelashes and your own natural upper lashes if they are not naturally black.

In years’ past, getting your hands on a safe yet effective product to plump and thicken lashes meant spending more money at a health food & beauty store or shopping online.  However, the rising popularity of natural and chemical-free cosmetics has made products like Physician’s Formula Organic Wear rise to the top for performance and safety as well; and, all from your local drugstore. However, you don’t have to spend around twenty dollars for organic picks for the best thickening mascara anymore, and you can finally snag yourself a bottle of quality, plumping mascara for under ten dollars, by conveniently shopping online, allowing you to have the best of both worlds – quality and convenience of home delivery.


The original creator of the MINKI LASHES E-MAGAZINE that covers everything from false eyelashes and eyelash extensions, eye makeup tips and ideas for all eye colors and eye shapes, to eye makeup product reviews and eye makeup ingredients safety. Your FAUX LASH AUTHORITY and founder of the soon-to-be-launched affordable luxury BRAND of cruelty-free 100% Siberian MINK LASHES and MINK EYELASH EXTENSIONS.

Check Also

Best Cheap Mascara

Best Cheap Mascara For Short Lashes – 10 Risky Options To Avoid!

Perusing the drugstore cosmetics aisles looking for the best cheap mascara for your short lashes …

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *